
This is a sorrowful tale of rejection and humiliation. Of sadness and shame. But if you read to the end you will find there’s a happy ending.
I was kicked out of a collaborative book group on the grounds that my two submissions had attracted “considerable negative feedback” from other members.
Ouch.
CHAPTER ONE
At left you can see my first submission to “The Crown Book”. There was no theme for this book, we just had to work on a specific shape. I took that to mean we could create a page in any style. So this is what I did with my page.
In a collaborative book swap you make multiple identical pages, then send them to the host, who re-assembles the pages into books that get re-distributed to all the participants.
I liked my page. And as there was no theme, I took the opportunity to say “be daring and different”. At the time I had just wound-up my art stamp business after years of making art samples using my stamps. At last I was free to create art anyway I liked - not just using the stamp images my company sold. I could sing with my own voice and get back to that child-like non-conformity. I felt really free and happy about this and I really like this simple happy girl (who, okay, happens to be me, but that wasn’t important) and the quote because it was so relevant to me at the time.
When the others in the collaborative book swap received their books in the mail, apparently they did not share in my enthusiasm for this page. I guess they later discussed it amongst themselves. But no one told me how they felt. I wish they had.
When I received my compiled crown book, I liked some of the pages from the other artists. I thought other pages were poorly executed or lacked solid design principles. Most of the pages had an image of a woman or girl cut from a vintage photo or a painting and glued to the background. Some had wings and crowns collaged on. Mainly there was an overuse of embellishments that detracted from the focal image. So I was disappointed in about a third of the pages. But I didn’t tell anyone. As the book had a spiral wire binding, I just removed the pages I didn’t like and threw them away. I felt a little guilty about doing that. And I decided that maybe this collaborative group I’d been invited to join, wasn’t actually my scene. Should I quit?
CHAPTER TWO
The group moderator sent out an email announcing a new collaborative book project, “The Mermaid’s Tale”. I love mermaids. I decided to give the group one more shot. We were sent eight die-cut pages in the shape of a mermaid/fish tail to use as pages. We needed to decorate them all the same, as before with the crown book. This time we had a sea theme, of course and were given a blue and green color scheme.
I wanted to use the tail shape creatively and came up with the idea of fitting a mermaid head into each side of the fin, then a shared torso and mermaid tail to create mermaids who were conjoined twins. I made the tail and the mermaids’ hair with textured impasto and painted them with Lumiere paints and I drew the faces and features with pen highlighted with chalks. It was quite a production to make eight pages, but I was pleased with the result. Then I added some text at the side which was supposed to look like the text you see in a box on a comic book page, but my pen was too thick and I wasn’t as thrilled about that as I’d been with the mermaids.
I shipped off my pages on schedule. After a delay, because others held up the process, I got my compiled book in the mail.
My page was on top. Yes, I loved the mermaids and still disliked that pen I used for the text. Then I looked at the other pages. Hmmm. There were elements I liked about some of them, but I’m sorry to say there wasn’t a single page in the whole book that I thought really worked as a piece of decorative art . Overall, this was more disappointing than the crown book. I am sure the women who participated in this swap have talent, but it wasn’t really showing on these pages. I wondered if the tail shape of the page had something to do with it.
And then it dawned on me: Each artist used a cut-out photo or painted image of a woman or mermaid. The members of this group weren’t really stretching themselves to create art in a unique, personal style. They were all cutting up other artists’ photos or art and pasting them into new compositions. It was as if they were all trying to use the same style. Was that a rule in this group, that I had somehow missed? You had to use collage?
AN ASIDE:
Now I love Lynn Whipple’s Ninnies and Claudine Helmuth’s Poppets. Teesha Moore and Lynne Perella - magic. These artists have each developed their own unique artistic styles, instantly recognisable. Yes, they all work in collage, using photos. I love their work. I respect what they do because they are the trend-setters. And their works tell stories. And every element on a page is selected and placed with care to compliment the whole effect.
And I don’t mean to put anyone off the more common, currently popular style of collage where you combine pictures of girls with butterfly wings and party hats. I’ve done it myself and it is fun. But if you want to stretch yourself, and if you want to “assert imaginative vision” push beyond. Don’t settle for being a “creature of the commonplace” or a “slave of the ordinary”.
CHAPTER THREE
I came home from my week in Ballarat to find two emails from the group moderator - first, a personal one to me: My work in the crown book and the mermaids tale book had attracted negative feedback and there was no other way to handle it but to remove me from the group.
Then there was the email she sent to the entire group: She was “applying a clean broom”, getting rid of those of us who were “below par”. The other members who worked within the rules had a right to play in a “safe environment”. So to ensure the valued members didn’t quit the group, she was removing those of us who were the worst, and giving warnings to the others who were merely mediocre.
Of course I was in the category of “out you go”.
Oh the shame. Oh the embarrassment.
I had been planning to quietly leave the group because the work coming from most others was of a low standard. And it turned out that the group thought MY standard of work was so low; so very, very low, that they wanted to GET RID OF ME, with trumpets and fanfare.
Can you imagine how painful that was?
I looked at my work with a critical eye. I was prepared to believe that it was true. Yes, it quite possibly was crap. Regardless of what I felt about the other group members’ work, my own work fell short of the mark. Maybe they took my crown book page for scrapbooking (crapbooking). Maybe the mermaid page was absolutely horrible. Maybe I sucked as a papercraft artist, always had done, and for years no one had ever had the guts to tell me.
I threw the Crown Book and the Mermaid’s Tale book into the rubbish bin. But not before I first removed my own pages. They might’ve been crap, but they were my crap and I liked them anyway.
CHAPTER FOUR (this is the happy ending bit)
When I got over my grief, I came to some important conclusions, that are now typed out and posted above my desk:
- I make art the way I want to make art … even if it is lousy art.
- My art shall be tied to my soul; not my ego.
- As I start to create, I set this intention: I work in my own artistic style.
I am grateful for this humbling experience because it forced me to look hard at how and why I make art. I was pretty stupid, not to notice that the other members were all working in a similar style. If I’d paid closer attention, I might have fallen into the trap of making imitative collage art … which would have been entertaining, yet would have distracted me from doing what I really want to do as an artist.
So here is a promise: I will never join a collaborative book project or swap again.
Never ever.